137 shares, 159 points

Source: Rebecca Spear / iMore

Pokémon video games are all enjoyable to play, however some Pokémon video games are higher than others. When followers of those JRPGs aren’t ready with bated breath for the latest era of video games, they’re questioning when their favourite video games will get remade. The current launch of Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl received me excited about which Pokémon remakes are the very best ones. So we have executed our greatest to rank them for you.

How the rating works

I’ve thought-about fairly just a few components when deciding to rank these video games. Here are the totally different standards we used for this checklist:

  • The scale of change from unique to remake: How totally different are the remakes from the originals?
  • Modernization: What quality-of-life adjustments had been added to make an older sport really feel extra trendy?
  • New options: What new, shiny options had been added to set the sport other than the unique?
  • Missteps: What options (or lack thereof) negatively affected the sport’s degree of enjoyment?

All Pokémon remakes ranked

Though these video games all function enhancements from their unique counterparts, some are higher than others. Four Pokémon areas have obtained the remake therapy, with Kanto double dipping for 2 of them: FireRed and LeafGreen on the Game Boy Advance, and the Let’s Go! video games on the Nintendo Switch.

5. Pokémon Let’s Go, Pikachu! and Let’s Go, Eevee! — Nintendo Switch

Pokémon: Let's Go plus a Poke BallSource: iMore

Pokémon Let’s Go! Pikachu and Eevee had been Game Freak’s try and capitalize on the success of Pokémon GO, the cell sport that is taken the world by storm since its debut in 2016. These video games weren’t explicitly marketed or handled just like the remakes we have come to count on. Instead, they had been marketed as a “reimagining” of Pokémon Yellow, with a deal with catching Pokémon to realize expertise, somewhat than battling them.

The spin-and-flick catching technique from Pokémon GO was applied, requiring gamers to make use of movement controls with the Joy-Con or the brand new Poké Ball Plus accent. This Poké Ball Plus each acted as a Nintendo Switch controller and as a Pokémon GO accent, and have become the one reputable technique to receive the legendary Pokémon, Mew.

Pokemon Let's Go MewSource: iMore/ Rene Ritchie

The Let’s Go! video games had been worlds other than their Game Boy counterparts, introducing mechanics like Dark and Fairy, splitting strikes into both bodily or particular by their traits as an alternative of their typing, and permitting Pokémon to comply with the participant round within the overworld. Players may even experience a number of Pokémon like Charizard, Snorlax, and Lapras. A neighborhood multiplayer co-op mode was added for battles and catching Pokémon, your Pokémon storage field may very well be accessed from virtually wherever, and the Experience Share merchandise now served all Pokémon in your get together as an alternative of only one.

Unfortunately, this entry did not provide a lot of a problem, and the Pokémon GO catching mechanics did not attraction to everybody. Seeing Pokémon within the overworld was good, however there was little alternative for trainers to showcase their JRPG expertise. Outside of coach battles and some legendary Pokémon, gamers could not interact within the wild battles that make these video games enjoyable for a lot of.

Motion controls in docked mode additionally had been compelled upon the participant, with no choice to make use of button controls exterior of handheld mode. The movement controls had been usually inaccurate and resulted in wasted Poké Balls, which was irritating even when the sport threw Poké Balls at you each likelihood it received. These components, paired with the repetitive catching, made this remake much less of a nostalgia journey and extra of a nostalgia slog.

4. Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen — Game Boy Advance

Pokemon Fire Red Leaf Green Game Boy Advance Gba SpSource: Rebecca Spear / iMore

Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen served because the very first remakes of the mainline Pokémon video games, setting the baseline for what it means to reimagine a whole area for extra trendy consoles. Introducing full coloration graphics, natures and IVs, and the choice to play as a woman, these video games on the Game Boy Advance made the unique Kanto video games look the best way gamers felt when experiencing the area for the primary time. Finally, gamers may dispose of janky and cumbersome Link Cables for buying and selling, as every sport got here bundled with a wi-fi adapter, making buying and selling and battling masses simpler.

Gameboy Advance Pokemon Firered Leafgreen Wireless AdapterSource: The Pokémon Company

FireRed and LeafGreen launched a whole new space stuffed with post-game content material known as the Sevii Islands, which featured expanded story content material and the power to catch Pokémon beforehand discovered within the Johto and Hoenn areas, together with legendary and legendary Pokémon. Though these video games got here lengthy earlier than the second Kanto remake, they provided tons extra post-game content material than the Nintendo Switch model of Kanto did.

Being the primary could be a blessing and a curse, although. While Johto and Hoenn Pokémon had been accessible within the sport, they might not be caught and even traded till gamers reached the post-game. This meant that gamers weren’t in a position to commerce with their associates if these associates had been additional alongside within the sport than they had been. This rule of Kanto-only Pokémon was so strict that even evolutions like Crobat and Kingdra weren’t accessible till the post-game. Though I perceive that Game Freak had no foundation to go off of, these arbitrary guidelines made taking part in with others troublesome.

3. Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl — Nintendo Switch

Pokemon Brilliant Diamond Shining Pearl Amity SquareSource: The Pokémon Company

Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl are devoted reimaginings of the primary Nintendo DS Pokémon duo, which introduced web connectivity and a worldwide Pokémon presence to many followers all over the world. They are the primary Pokémon video games outsourced to a different developer, ILCA, which opted to stay to the chibi artstyle that extra carefully resembled the pixel artwork of the unique video games somewhat than go full 3D the best way the Let’s Go! video games did.

The transition from a dual-screen sport on the Nintendo DS to a single-screen sport on the Nintendo Switch ended up being smoother than anticipated, with the choice to position the Pokétch in a single nook being one of many welcome variations. Players additionally now not wanted to sacrifice a celebration slot to maintain a Bidoof as an “HM slave,” as the unique video games had been well-known for blocking tons of areas behind Hidden Moves like Defog. This time round, HMs are executed by wild Pokémon as an alternative.

Pokemon Brilliant Diamond Shining Pearl PiplupSource: The Pokémon Company

Despite followers clamboring to get their arms on the Sinnoh remakes, what resulted was a somewhat hole reception. It was a 1:1 remake in virtually each sense of the phrase, right down to the omission of additional content material featured in Pokémon Platinum that made Sinnoh really feel extra attention-grabbing and vibrant. There was no Battle Frontier, no Distortion World the place Giratina resides, and bugs across the sport’s launch that made the sport unplayable for some.

Nothing large was taken away from Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, however after the discharge of the following two video games on this checklist, nothing large felt added, both. Pokémon can comply with you within the overworld, however proportions and animations may very well be off-putting. The Sinnoh remakes additionally failed to incorporate all presently accessible Pokémon the best way the opposite three mainline remakes did on the time of their launch, which means that Game Freak was severe after they mentioned that each one Pokémon will now not be accessible in all video games after the massive Dexit controversy. When I consider these restrictions, they overshadow the great elements and find yourself failing to push these in any other case good and shining video games to the highest.

2. Pokémon Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire — Nintendo 3DS

Pokemon Omega RubySource: The Pokémon Company

Though some say these video games had an excessive amount of water, I assumed they had been improbable. I performed these remakes across the time I received my arms on Pokémon Emerald for the primary time, and I noticed firsthand how a lot they improved these video games from the originals. One factor that dissatisfied me was the shortage of a Battle Frontier, with it being depicted as “under construction,” however there was a lot extra anyway.

Flying over Hoenn on a legendary Pokémon pushed the Nintendo 3DS to its limits; Game Freak needed to point out gamers what Hoenn would have appeared like if that they had the sources again within the days of the Game Boy Advance. The new and returning Mega Evolutions, integrations with Streetpass via the distribution of the Eon Ticket, the sheer degree of customization that went into constructing your Super Secret Base, having the ability to go to different Super Secret Bases and battle trainers, and rather more gave Hoenn traditional options whereas incorporating trendy mechanics liked by followers to today.

Pokemon TIMESource: The Pokémon Company

An complete new post-game story was added with the Delta Episode, permitting the legendary Pokémon Deoxys to be catchable for the primary time with out having to go to a bodily location for an unique occasion. As somebody who grew up with restricted entry to video games and related occasions, options like Streetpass and in-game occasions had been very a lot appreciated.

1. Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver — Nintendo DS

Pokemon Heart Gold Soul Silver PokewalkerSource: The Pokémon Company

This determination was onerous to make, as each the Johto and Hoenn remakes maintain a particular place in my coronary heart. But there is a cause why HeartGold and SoulSilver are sometimes cited as being the very best Pokémon video games ever — to not point out being the costliest Pokémon video games on the secondhand market and a few of the most closely counterfeited Pokémon video games. The Johto remakes introduced Gold, Silver and Crystal to new heights.

The bodily/particular break up, integration of timed occasions utilizing the Nintendo DS’ inside clock, day by day and weekly occasions, Pokémon following the participant, the power to switch Pokémon from earlier generations, the Battle Frontier, and the improved music make this sport the one one I care to revisit many times. Not to say we received the PokéWalker, which was basically Pokémon GO earlier than smartphones. It inspired children to get out and stroll round, with objects and unique Pokémon as rewards.

Pokemon SoulsilverSource: @Nintendo Utopia on YouTube

HeartGold and SoulSilver made Johto and Kanto really feel trendy within the truest sense of the phrase whereas constructing off of Diamond and Pearl to make the expertise on the Nintendo DS as satisfying as attainable. Better UI, touchscreen integration, and fast-paced gameplay by no means made me impatient in the best way that Sinnoh as soon as did. The inclusion of two complete areas about doubles your playtime, with Kanto serving as a New Game+ of types.

I binged this sport in a weekend as a baby, and was totally shocked on the sport’s means to suck me in as a lot because it did. These video games are the proper marriage of content material and problem, and may era 5 obtain a remake as properly, they will have this one to cope with.

Are there extra to come back?

Each of the Pokémon remakes had one thing distinctive to supply. As time goes on, followers have sure expectations for what they need out of remakes, as they’re seen because the “definitive” editions of every area. We’re unsure if Game Freak intends to proceed making remakes, or whether or not the Let’s Go! video games level in direction of a number of remakes per area. What we do know, nonetheless, is that every era of Pokémon video games met us as a special time in our lives, and the sensation of nostalgia when leaping again into acquainted locales is definitely unmatched.

Let’s go, Sinnoh!

Pokemon Brilliant Diamond Shining Pearl Titles

Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl

Embark on an epic journey

Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl are beautiful remakes of the favored Nintendo DS titles that had been first launched in 2006. Explore the world, full your Pokédex, and battle it out throughout eight gyms and numerous Pokémon trainers, all dressed up in a tremendous chibi type.

We might earn a fee for purchases utilizing our hyperlinks. Learn extra.

Like it? Share with your friends!

137 shares, 159 points

What's Your Reaction?

confused confused
lol lol
hate hate
fail fail
fun fun
geeky geeky
love love
omg omg
win win