166 shares, 188 points

References to Afilias have been noticed within the technical necessities for the contract to run the stylish top-level area .television, suggesting the method is strongly stacked within the web registry operator’s favor.

If you are having déjà vu, it is as a result of we blew the lid off the very same factor within the battle over Colombia’s .co.

In a story final Thursday, we reported that the tiny island nation of Tuvalu, which owns .television, has invited corporations to bid on the fitting to promote .television domains.

Crucially, we revealed the bizarre and illogical stipulations to win this profitable contract. For occasion, regardless of there being solely 500,000 .television domains, the federal government of Tuvalu mentioned whoever needed to run the top-level area wanted to have carried out “at least 3 transitions of TLDs over 1 million domain names.” Not solely that however the profitable bidder additionally has to have transitioned “at least 5 TLDs, and at least 5 ccTLDs.”

We have now been capable of affirm that in the very same manner Colombia’s technical necessities for .co have been seemingly tailor-made for Afilias, language within the .television fine-print additionally immediately references the registry operator.

Tuvalu’s .television registry has been run for the previous 20 years by Verisign, but below the standards printed by the Tuvalu authorities, the dot-com big wouldn’t be eligible to proceed working it.

Nor would GoDaddy Registry, which lately purchased registry operations from Neustar, and says it owns, manages, or operates greater than 240 top-level domains. And nor would Centralnic, which runs not less than 50 top-level-domain backends.

In every case, these opponents to Afilias fail to satisfy one side of .television’s necessities, giving Tuvalu’s authorities a easy technique to hand the contract over to Afilias with out having to deal with the bids on different standards equivalent to worth, technical requirements, and repair ranges. The bidding course of can be being held in secret, behind closed doorways.

We perceive that one other invited bidder for .television is auDA, the corporate that runs Australia’s .au top-level area. But auDA itself makes use of the Afilias platform so it’s successfully the identical.

Not within the public curiosity

In the case of Colombia’s .co rebid final yr, the formal necessities for the TLD repeatedly cited Public Interest Registry, or PIR, the corporate that runs .org and whose technical backend is offered by Afilias. It appeared somebody tuned the .co standards to align them with Afilias’s capabilities, clearing the way in which for it to bag the .co contract.

There was no purpose why .org’s PIR would function in technical necessities for a totally completely different top-level area, and its inclusion was seen as a careless try and award the gig to a particular applicant by stealth. It additionally did not assist that Afilias CTO Ram Mohan was pictured sitting subsequent to Colombia’s IT minister Sylvia Constaín at a round-table in Bogota months earlier.


Ever needed to personal a bit of the web? Now you possibly can: $1 for a complete gTLD… or $2.8m if you would like an honest one


A spokesperson for Afilias denied something untoward occurred, telling us on the time final yr: “We have not met with the technology minister or the technology ministry in private to provide advice or documents regarding the .co tender.” Constaín additionally mentioned all the things was above board, and resigned for a job within the non-public sector.

We have but to see any footage of Afilias bosses getting cozy with Tuvalu authorities officers, and we now have requested the corporate to state if there have been any conferences or discussions with the island nation relating to its top-level area. In the meantime, would you consider it? Afilias reveals up once more within the .television information.

Included within the technical necessities is a reference to abuse safety service NameSentry – full with its service-mark image.

Most of the most important registry operators provide some form of abuse safety however just one affords NameSentry: Afilias acquired the service when it sued one other area safety firm, Architelos, out of business in 2016. As a consequence, NameSentry is inextricably linked to Afilias.

There isn’t any purpose why NameSentry could be recognized particularly in technical documentation produced by the Tuvalu authorities.

What a coincidence

Taken collectively, Afilias – which is owned by domains big Donuts since December – has, once more, discovered itself name-checked within the necessities to run a TLD that its rivals have been ostensibly invited to bid on. Afilias has ignored our requests for remark and our provide to let it inform its aspect of this story.

Last time round, amid media stress on the Colombian authorities to elucidate itself, Afilias withdrew its bid for .co and the contract for working the top-level area went again to its incumbent operator, Neustar.

As a much smaller nation, with simply over 10,000 inhabitants (versus Colombia’s 50 million), Tuvalu does not have a lot of an impartial, free press. There is a digital publication, run by the federal government, and a single non-public newspaper, run by the Justice minister Dr Kitiona Tausi.

If Tuvaluans need to get the very best deal from their most respected digital asset, they’d do nicely to take a more in-depth take a look at the .television rebid. ®

Like it? Share with your friends!

166 shares, 188 points

What's Your Reaction?

confused confused
lol lol
hate hate
fail fail
fun fun
geeky geeky
love love
omg omg
win win